Students with Social, Emotional and Mental Health (SEMH) needs are among the most vulnerable in our school communities. They are disproportionately represented in exclusion statistics and their needs are often misunderstood.
When we take the time to listen to these students and promote their voice, we can uncover insightful strategies come from the students themselves. This article shares findings from a ‘Pupil Voice Project’ that captured the voices of 13 secondary students with SEMH needs, using participatory research methods and focus groups, across three secondary schools who shared what helps them thrive in school.
Their insights, grounded in psychological theory and best practice, can offer powerful and practical guidance for support.
Background
Research highlights students with SEMH needs struggle with trust, emotional regulation, and belonging. These challenges are often compounded in school systems. It is understandable that can teachers feel overwhelmed when faced with complex behaviour or emotional outbursts. But drawing on both psychological frameworks and the lived experiences and views of the students themselves, can support our understanding of supportive strategies.
Understanding Through Psychology
- Attachment and Trauma-Informed Approaches
Many students with SEMH needs have experienced disrupted attachments or trauma. Feeling safe and seen at school is essential. Teachers can act as secure bases, building trust through consistency and relational approaches. - Self-Determination Theory
Autonomy, competence, and relatedness are key for motivation and wellbeing. When students feel they have choice, feel capable, and feel connected, they engage more. - Ecological Systems Theory
SEMH support must be holistic, involving collaboration between school, families, and wider systems. Whole-school ethos matters just as much as individual interventions. - Pupil Voice in Practice
Despite their insights, pupils with SEMH needs are often the least heard. Yet research shows when we do listen, we uncover rich knowledge that improves practice and empowers students.

What Pupils Told Us (and What It Means for Practice):
1. Time for Relationships
“Teachers expect you to automatically trust them and tell them everything”
At the heart of effective support is a strong, trusting relationship. Pupils emphasised the importance of friendships for belonging, as well as adults taking time to understand them and the importance of mutual respect. Consistency, curiosity, and small gestures, like greeting students by name or checking in, can build the trust that’s essential for engagement.
2. Safe Spaces and Time to Regulate
“When I have my head down, I don’t want to have a chat”
“Take me out of lessons and talk to me”
Many students need time and space to process emotions and language. Quiet areas, sensory spaces, or simply being allowed to step out of class can help them regulate. These strategies should be seen as part of emotional support, not as rewards or avoidance.
3. Movement and Practical Strategies
“Walking around helps”
Physical movement helps with concentration and regulation. Opportunities for movement breaks, physical activities, or alternative seating can support attention and behaviour. Simple tools like fidget items or access to clubs can also make a significant difference.
4. Individualised and Flexible Support
“Giving more time to write stuff down”
Students value when their specific needs are recognised and accommodated. Adjustments like extra processing time, breaking down instructions, or use of assistive technology make learning more accessible.
5. Autonomy, Motivation and Choice
Pupils want to feel a sense of control over their learning and school experience. Providing meaningful choices, such as where to sit, how to approach tasks, or selecting subjects, supports autonomy, self-esteem and engagement. Involving students in reward systems or goal setting can boost motivation.
6. Practical, Interactive Learning
“Looking at a whiteboard all day doesn’t help”
Students with SEMH needs respond well to hands-on and real-life learning that connects with their interests and future aspirations. Group work, practical tasks, and use of technology were all valued.
7. Nurturing, Relational Approach
“We should be motivated and encouraged to do the right thing”
Students respond best when staff show empathy and seek to understand the roots of their behaviour rather than relying on punitive responses. Nurture-based approaches, emotional literacy support, and consistent encouragement help them make positive choices and feel safe to take risks in learning.
Conclusion.
The perspectives shared by the students align strongly with what research and psychology advocate for: relationships, trust, autonomy, flexibility, and a move toward relational, trauma-informed approaches, which are essential for meaningful engagement and wellbeing. When we listen to what the students tell us, we not only strengthen our practice, but we also empower young people to feel seen, valued, and capable of thriving in school.

Useful Resources: